Are Eggs Really As Bad As Smoking?

CoachMel Healthy Eating 9 Comments

A new study claims eggs may be on par with cigarettes in terms of how bad they are for heart health.

Perhaps you’ve heard this, and have been fretting that your beloved and dependable eggs were all of a sudden a poor breakfast choice.

But, fear not!

NEW VISITOR BONUS: Download a Free Guide
How To Lose Weight Fast in 3 Simple Steps (Based on Science).

Great! Where should I send the guide?
Send Me The Guide >>
Follow these steps to lose 10 pounds in a week

As you know, I’m a big fan of eating eggs for breakfast, but not at the expense of my own health, or yours.

So, I was keen to check out this study, and see what all the hype was about.

Thankfully, I’m not alone in my conclusions, with many health professionals and others speaking out in support of the humble little egg.

The Study: Are Eggs Bad For You?

The study, which took the form of a survey, asked just over 1,200 stroke patients about their egg consumption and cigarette habit.

They concluded that eating egg yolks on a regular basis is approximately two-thirds as bad as smoking, in terms of the buildup of plaque in the arteries.

Researchers also noted those who were oldest ate the most eggs, and had the most plaque. From this they surmised that eggs must be the cause.

However, previous studies have already shown that as you get older, more plaque builds up.

So, I would suggest the higher plaque noted in older individuals, is simply the result of aging. It does not necessarily show a ’cause’ and ‘effect,’ that is, eating eggs leads to plaque buildup.

As you know, I don’t make a habit of detailing the weaknesses of every study that is published. However, this study was flawed from the outset, and given the media’s unreasonable coverage of these results, I felt is was something important to discuss.

The Research Flaws

1. Clear Conflict Of Interest

I think it’s important to point out that two of the researchers in this study (Spence and Davignon) have extensive ties to the statin industry.

(See the ‘footnote’ at the bottom of this research paper.)

It seems pretty obvious that the companies who produce statins (cholesterol lowering drugs) might just have a vested interest in making us all afraid of eggs and cholesterol.

Call me crazy, but I find it hard to believe this is not a massive conflict of interest.

2. Self Reported Evidence

The data collected was based on self reported evidence. This is highly inaccurate and dependent on each subjects memory and honesty.

In fact, the authors acknowledge their results are rather weak. This has not, however, stopped the media jumping on these claims, and running with them like a dog with a new bone.

I suppose, “Eggs Are Nearly As Bad For Your Arteries As Cigarettes,” as one newspaper claimed, makes a great headline.

In case you don’t realize the utter uselessness of this type of study design, here’s a test for you…

Try to remember how many eggs you ate over the entire year in 2011.

I’m sure you get the point!

Expecting people to remember accurately how many eggs they consumed last year is impossible, never mind trying to recall every last egg they’ve ever eaten.

At best you could make an educated guess. But, that kind of data is close to useless in terms of a scientific study.

3. Didn’t Look At Egg Preparation

When asked about egg consumption, the researchers did not take into consideration how the eggs were prepared, neither were they queried about what had been consumed along with those eggs.

Think about it, the stuff a lot of people eat with their eggs is usually sausages, bacon, breads and vegetable oils. There are also the other foods that contain eggs, like cookies and mayonnaise.

I’d hazard a guess that at least some of those questioned were eating unhealthy foods along with their egg.

For this research to have been taken seriously, it’s an absolute must that this was accounted for. It wasn’t!

4. Comparing “Apples” With “Pears”

Then, there’s the nonsense of equating cigarette smoking with eating eggs.

This makes no sense. At. All.

If eggs were to have an impact on heart disease it would be indirect. That is, the eggs have to first increase cholesterol levels to create plaque buildup.

Smoking, on the other hand, has a direct impact on heart disease, because smoking causes arteries to become inflamed, which makes the body respond and make plaque.

Therefore, although is may sound convincing to claim, “Egg yolks appears to be approximately 2/3 that of smoking,” is doesn’t make sense.

The Research Has Been Criticized

Dr. Steven Nissen, who chairs the department of Cardiovascular Medicine at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation, said;

This is very poor quality research that should not influence patient’s dietary choices.

I couldn’t agree more!

How To Keep Your Heart Healthy

There are a few important things you can do to reduce your risk of heart disease, which do not include avoiding eggs.

1. Balance Your Fat Ratio

Many people are eating fats in an unbalanced ratio. One study emphasized this by saying:

Excessive amounts of omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) and a very high omega-6/omega-3 ratio, as is found in today’s Western diets, promote the pathogenesis of many diseases, including cardiovascular disease, cancer, and inflammatory and autoimmune diseases, whereas increased levels of omega-3 PUFA (a low omega-6/omega-3 ratio) exert suppressive effects.

In particular, you should try to lower the amount of vegetable oils in your diet, and eat high quality, animal-based sources of omega 3 fats.

2. Take Regular Exercise

Studies show exercise helps to lower inflammation in atherosclerosis, without any of the side effects of taking medication.

So, try to exercise regularly, and make sure you are adding some high intensity interval training in there, too.

3. Reduce Your Waist Size

If you carry too much weight around your waist, this is particularly problematic, since research shows this as a strong risk factor for plaque buildup.

Losing those extra inches will go a long way towards solving the problem.

As a very rough guideline:

  • Men should try to keep their waist circumference well under 40 inches.
  • Women should try to keep their waist circumference well under 35 inches.

To measure your waist circumference, place the tape measure around the smallest area of your abdomen below your rib cage and above your belly button.

Also, don’t smoke!

What do you think, are eggs bad for you? Do you eat them regularly?

Image source

NEW VISITOR BONUS: Download a Free Guide
How To Lose Weight Fast in 3 Simple Steps (Based on Science).

Great! Where should I send the guide?
Send Me The Guide >>
Follow these steps to lose 10 pounds in a week

Don't Miss The Awesomeness!

Join the Rebel Newsletter for the unadulterated truth on health, weight loss, and lifestyle excellence. What are you waiting for?

Comments 9

  1. Richard

    I hadn’t heard that egg’s where bad for you, but by the end of your article I was sure that eggs weren’t bad for you, so I’m happy again 🙂

  2. Cathy in NZ

    Yes, certainly egg and bacon (or similar) will be bad for you! Not the EGG of course but the additives. Linked to maybe a day of not exercising, eating other ‘relatively wrong things’

    I don’t actually eat many ‘eggs’ as such other than in baked goods. Mainly because if none are in the house, often happens, no eggs are eaten.

    But when they are in the house, I have a tendency to make an omelette which will be added to something else. For the protein item.

    1. Melanie

      Hi Tony,
      Yes, we probably need to be even more suspicious when the media grab onto a topic like this. Perhaps it’s a good indication to switch off!!

  3. Melinda

    I usually have an egg scrambled with spinach, onions,and peppers wrapped in a small tortilla for breakfast. I don’t usually eat eggs any other time throughout the day unless they are in something I am baking or occasionally in a salad. I usually don’t pay too much attention to studies about food because it just seems that everything is bad for you in some way or another. I try to eat in moderation, drink plenty water, and exercise. If God put it on this earth for food, then I eat it. So I really don’t eat much packaged, processed foods. That’s what works for me.

    1. Melanie

      I love your comment Melinda, and I couldn’t agree more actually. When these studies come out we always need to ask ourselves, “who benefits,” because it seems to me there is often an ulterior motive to be promoted. As you say, eat close to nature, just as God intended us to. Thanks for your comment.

  4. Joshua

    No Eggs are defenately healthy. After all a chicken feeds on one as a pre-born chick for three weeks before it hatches. If you want to be fit and healthy and loose weight just cut out two of your three meals a day and replace them with a single fried or boiled egg on a slice of toast along with a large glass of water 20 minutes after eating the egg meal.

    Smoking, though a non smoker myself, in my family there have over the last three generations, smokers and non smokers, Plenty of heart problems but never any cancer. The British cancer council over sevral years ran an anti smoking scare campaign blaming mouth, throat and stomach cancer on smoking. It worked! Millions stopped smoking, but the incidence of these cancers has more than doubled. The British cancer council as other cancer councils around the globe receive millions in funding. So now they alongside smoking are blaming alcohol. One of the real culprits of these cancers is quite simple but never mentioned “Fluoride” mainly in toothpaste, mouthwash and drinking water. Yes it gives you “The ring of confidence”. However the problem is not only does it kill good bacteria but also the good bacteria that are needed to protect your throat, mouth, lungs and stomach, thus leading to attack from infection and cancer. Answer is use toothpaste that is made up of natural products such as Aloe vera that protects the teeth, is kinder on the stomach and does not kill good bacteria your body needs. With regards to drinking water containing fluoride and chlorine I understand a good water filter containing carbon will filter out fluoride. A small research group in the US even stated that cigarette smoke in the mouth and throat even promotes or enhances the good bacteria your body needs.

    Finally I used to smoke but gave it away many years ago. I do not like the smell of burning tobacco but in all fairness I think the real truth and full truth should be given on smoking, not the “over the top” hype and propaganda that is foisted onto the public just so they can keep raking in the millions.

    Instead of the over the top scare tactics why cannot these groups put profits aside for once and tell the public the real truth of the matter?

    1. Melanie

      Hi Joshua, that wouldn’t make them enough money, I suppose. You raise some interesting topics here. I’ve never questioned the idea that tobacco causes cancer, actually. As far as fluoride is concerned, I am not a fan either. We try not to use it in our toothpaste, and thankfully our drinking water doesn’t have it in… yet. It is something I want to research more, but I would certainly be protesting if they try to put it in our water.

      It seems you can’t trust the official advice anymore. Vaccines are another issue where hype and propaganda are used to scare the public!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *