The Negative Calorie Food Myth Busted!

CoachMel Weight Loss Tips 20 Comments

This dieting concept sounds so good you really do want to believe it’s true.

That is, the idea of negative calorie foods

Basically, some foods require more energy to digest than the calories contained within the food, and so eating them will help you lose weight.

NEW VISITOR BONUS: Download a Free Guide
How To Lose Weight Fast in 3 Simple Steps (Based on Science).

Great! Where should I send the guide?
Send Me The Guide >>
Follow these steps to lose 10 pounds in a week

Citrus fruits and celery have both basked in this flattering light down through the years. But, you may have heard anything from cabbage to spinach to grapefruit being called a negative calorie food.

Let’s take celery as an example.

It’s pretty much empty from a nutritional standpoint, made up of water, sodium, some nutrients, and fiber (cellulose). A large stalk of celery contains about 10 calories.

So, negative calorie advocates claim that the process of chewing and digesting this stalk of celery requires more energy than the calories contained in the celery, which means it has negative calories.

Sounds like a win-win option, but is there any substance to this theory?

Unfortunately, this is another of those silly nutrition myths that gets tossed about as truth, but has a severe lack of scientific backing.

Main Issues With The Negative Calorie Theory

There are some important flaws to bear in mind when thinking about this whole idea of negative calories.

Too Simplistic

Firstly, the theory is far too simplistic.

The digestive system obviously needs calories for fuel, however the calories your body burns for digestion are minuscule compared with the calories in the food itself.

Here’s a breakdown of the 3 factors which have an impact on energy expenditure (EE), to emphasize my point further;

  • Thermic Effect of Food (10% of EE): the number of calories required to digest, absorb, transport, and store food.
  • Basal Metabolic Rate (60-70% of EE): the number of calories the body needs to maintain body functions at rest.
  • Physical Activity (20-30% of EE): the number of calories expended during daily activity and exercise.

As you can see, your body only uses 10 percent of the calories you take in across a whole day, to fuel digestion, and store nutrients from the foods you eat.

If we take celery as our scapegoat example again, it is true to say that it’s low in calories.

But, it’s an awful leap to say that the body burns more calories chewing and digesting foods like celery, simply because they are a bit more difficult to digest than other foods.

There’s just no evidence of this being the case.

Food List Is Nonsensical

I find it difficult to get my head around this list of so-called negative calorie foods.

In fact, I really cannot say why they have been dubbed as such, other than that they all have a relatively high water and cellulose content;

  • Asparagus
  • Beet Root
  • Broccoli
  • Cabbage
  • Carrot
  • Cauliflower
  • Celery
  • Chicory
  • Hot Chili
  • Cucumber
  • Garden cress
  • Garlic
  • Green Beans
  • Lettuce
  • Onion
  • Radish
  • Spinach
  • Turnip
  • Zucchini
  • Apple
  • Blueberries
  • Cantaloupe
  • Cranberry
  • Grapefruit
  • Honeydew
  • Lemon/Lime
  • Mango
  • Orange
  • Papaya
  • Peach
  • Pineapple
  • Raspberry
  • Strawberry
  • Tomato
  • Tangerine
  • Turnip
  • Watermelon

Fruit Cannot Be A Negative Calorie Food

Including fruit in this list of negative calorie foods, is extremely confusing.

Typically fruit does contain a lot of water, with some indigestible fiber. But, it is also very high in natural sugars.

Just to be clear, there are natural sugars contained in vegetables, too, but for the most part, this is less than that contained in fruit.

Anyhow, suggesting you will burn more calories digesting fruit, than the calories present in the fruit, is complete nonsense.

A one cup serving of raspberries, for example, has 64 calories, 14.7g carbs and 5.4g sugar. One cup of watermelon has 46 calories, 11.5g carbs and 9.4g sugar.

While the calorie content of these fruits are certainly low, there is no way your body is going to burn in excess of 64 calories (or 46 calories in the case of the watermelon) simply by digesting these fruits.

This notion defies bio-chemistry, and the Laws of Thermodynamics.

The Lowdown on Negative Calorie Foods

The idea of negative calorie foods is based on very little scientific evidence.

Fruits and vegetables are indeed low in calories, high in antioxidants, vitamins, minerals and phytochemicals, and they are also very filling, so obviously a diet rich in these foods is a good thing, and will help you to lose or maintain your weight.

But, in terms of putting you into a magical negative calorie zone, don’t hold your breath!

Boost Your Metabolism Naturally With Diet

There are a number of ways to boost your metabolism, and these tips are more than just some notion.

(Obviously, exercise is another way, particularly through building muscle, which is more metabolically demanding than fat, but I want to focus on what we eat and drink, for the purposes of this article.)

1. Regular Meals

There is evidence that an irregular meal frequency may lead to weight gain.

Researchers compared the effect of eating anywhere from 3 to 9 meals per day, and found that;

Irregular meal frequency led to a lower postprandial energy expenditure compared with the regular meal frequency, while the mean energy intake was not significantly different between the two. The reduced TEF (thermic effect of food) with the irregular meal frequency may lead to weight gain in the long term.

2. Protein

Protein is often discussed in relation to weight loss for its satiating ability.

But, studies also show it has thermogenic fat burning characteristics. One study concluded;

There is convincing evidence that a higher protein intake increases thermogenesis and satiety compared to diets of lower protein content. The weight of evidence also suggests that high protein meals lead to a reduced subsequent energy intake.

Another study found that thermogenesis was significantly higher after consumption of the protein-rich meal in comparison to a fat-rich meal;

The results indicate that DIT (diet-induced thermogenesis) is higher after protein intake than after fat intake in both lean and obese participants.

3. Spicy Foods

It might sound like another quack recommendation, but there is at least some evidence to support this idea, too.

Researchers have found that spicy foods, like chili pepper, mustard, cinnamon, ginger, ginseng, guarana, and turmeric may have an effect on metabolism.

One study on Thai women concluded;

 Within 30 min after consumption of 5 g of Capsicum frutescens, plasma glucose level during the absorption period was significantly inhibited. The metabolic rate was also immediately increased after ingestion and sustained up to 30 min.

4. Water

We often say that drinking water aids weight loss, but is there any proof?

Well, one study found that water consumption increased metabolic rate by as much as 30%;

Drinking 2 liters of water per day would augment energy expenditure by approximately 400 kJ. Therefore, the thermogenic effect of water should be considered when estimating energy expenditure, particularly during weight loss programs.

They suggest that up to 40% of this increase in calorie burn was the result of the body attempting to heat the water, which is probably why ‘ice cold’ water is bandied about as an aid to weight loss.

What are your thoughts on negative calorie foods?

Image source

NEW VISITOR BONUS: Download a Free Guide
How To Lose Weight Fast in 3 Simple Steps (Based on Science).

Great! Where should I send the guide?
Send Me The Guide >>
Follow these steps to lose 10 pounds in a week

Don't Miss The Awesomeness!

Join the Rebel Newsletter for the unadulterated truth on health, weight loss, and lifestyle excellence. What are you waiting for?
GET FREE UPDATES

Comments 20

  1. Liz from FitSmarty

    Thanks! Lot of quality information here.
    I agree that “negative calorie foods” are just another try to have a shortcut that actually does not exist.
    About irregular meals: is the reduced thermic effect really worth mentioning? It seems to me that the greatest problem with irregular meals is that you just get really hungry and eat more than you normally would.
    Isn’t this “eating more” problem so much bigger than reduced thermic effect that eating more just outranks the other?

  2. Caitlin

    This was a fascinating post! I had recently heard that eating celery burned more calories than were actually contained in the veggie itself…it’s good to know that’s not true!

    As an avid water drinker (I drink at least 3 liters a day), it’s good to know my efforts are not in vain and help boost my metabolism. An added note here: I find that when I run, drinking water also gives me the ability to go farther and faster. The boost I need to be sure!

  3. George

    Interesting topic. I never really bought into the negative calorie idea myself. Drinking water can help though as you discussed. I read one study showing that drinking water can increase the metabolism for about an hour. A pretty nifty way of burning calories. Drinking a couple cups before meals can help you control your appetite leading to weight loss.

  4. Greg

    Good day. I have lost 60 kg over the last 2 years following a high protein diet. I have 20 kgs to go to reach my goal weight. I am unfortunately now left with bags of loose skin around my tummy that I would estimate must be 10 of the 20 kgs!
    Apart from plastic surgery that my Medical Aid will not cover, is there anything else I could do to reduce this skin as after all the effort of dieting and exercise it such a demotivating eyesore?
    Thank you for your assistance!
    Greg

  5. michael kors grayson satchel jet set

    First off I want to say awesome blog! I had a quick question in which I’d like to ask if you do not mind. I was interested to know how you center yourself and clear your head before writing. I’ve had a tough time clearing my mind in getting my thoughts out there. I do enjoy writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are generally wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any suggestions or hints? Appreciate it!|掲示板}
    michael kors grayson satchel jet set

  6. plumdale uggs for women

    Please let me know if you’re looking for a article author for your blog. You have some really great posts and I think I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please blast me an e-mail if interested. Many thanks!
    plumdale uggs for women

  7. chateau parka hinta

    I do enjoy the way you have framed this concern plus it does indeed present us some fodder for consideration. On the other hand, from what precisely I have observed, I just trust as other feed-back pile on that people today stay on issue and not start upon a tirade involving the news du jour. Anyway, thank you for this outstanding point and even though I can not concur with the idea in totality, I value the point of view.
    chateau parka hinta

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *